Trunk disease management tool

Photo: EscaPhoto: Eutypa diebackPhoto: Phomopsis diebackPhoto: Eutypa dieback

Figure variables

Cumulative Discounted Net Returns: The cumulative net returns (returns − costs) per acre over 25 years for a healthy vineyard, an untreated infected vineyard, and infected vineyards where action is taken. Current and future dollar amounts are in 2013 dollars and are discounted to 2013 using a 3% discount rate.

Table variables

Additional Cumulative Discounted Net Benefits (ACDNB): The difference in cumulative net returns (returns - costs) per acre over 25 years between an infected vineyard where action is taken and an untreated infected vineyard. Current and future dollar amounts are in 2013 dollars and are discounted to 2013 using a 3% discount rate.

As a reference point, here are the discounted cumulative net benefits for a healthy and an untreated infected vineyard.

Healthy vineyard Infected-untreated vineyard
Region (Crush District number) NB per acre
Napa (4) $203,982 $42,271
Northern San Joaquin (11) $33,019 -$11,957
Central Coast (8) $59,372 -$6,144
Lake (2) $40,375 -$4,601
Sonoma (3) $49,496 -$31,975

View fullscreen

Last Profitable Year: The last year an infected vineyard generates positive annual net returns (returns - costs). This year is the same for discounted and nominal net returns.

As a reference point, here are the last years an untreated infected vineyard generates positive annual net returns.

Region (Crush District number) Age
Napa (4) 14
Northern San Joaquin (11) 12
Central Coast (8) 12
Lake (2) 13
Sonoma (3) 12

View fullscreen

Age Adoption Pays Off: The age when cumulative discounted net returns (returns – costs) for a treated infected vineyard exceed those from an untreated infected vineyard.

Infection Probability Threshold: The probability of infection where expected cumulative discounted net returns from treating a vineyard equals the expected cumulative discounted net returns from not treating a vineyard. If you perceive a probability of infection less than this probability, then not treating the vineyard generates greater cumulative discounted net returns than a treated vineyard, and vice versa.

As a reference point here are the cumulative discounted net returns for a treated healthy vineyard.

Year 3 Year 5 Year 10
Region (Crush District number)
Napa (4)
     Hand painted Topsin $202,876 $203,005 $203,295
     Double Pruning $196,573 $197,435 $199,380
Northern San Joaquin (11)
     Hand painted Topsin $31,647 $31,806 $32,167
     Double Pruning $28,787 $29,280 $30,390
Central Coast (8)
     Hand painted Topsin $56,844 $57,138 $57,802
     Double Pruning $53,586 $54,259 $55,778
Lake (2)
     Hand painted Topsin $56,021 $56,122 $56,350
     Double Pruning $52,519 $53,028 $54,175
Sonoma (3)
     Topsin $48,345 $48,479 $48,781
     Double Pruning $44,304 $44,908 $46,271

View fullscreen

Back to decision tool